Most of the jokes I remember most are those I learned before I was 15. Like this one:
A boy is having his arm set in a cast and asks the doctor if he will be able to play the violin when his arm is healed. “Why sure!” answered the doctor. “You should be able to play the violin just fine.”
“That’s good,” said the boy. “I’ve always wanted to play the violin, but I never could before.”
Yeah, its lame I know. But at 6:00 this morning when I was halfway through my 4 mile jog on our town’s Greenway, it was one of the things that came to mind between songs on Beatles-A-Rama.
I’ve never thought of myself as a runner. There was always an excuse. I’m too fat. I want to protect my knees. I get bored. The list is long. And it started early.
When I was attending Charles Elementary in Richmond, IN, we had to run in PE class. I hated it. Not because I couldn’t do it. I could. I was an outdoorsy, skinny, always running around the neighborhood kind of kid. But I was bored with it. And I didn’t do it well. It wasn’t a natural gift for me. If you had to graph out the results of all the kids in our grade level who ran the mile in PE, it might look like this:

Students are divided into quintiles. The red line represents the accepted state standard pace which all students are supposed to achieve. As you can see, there are some kids who just naturally thrive above the line. There are some kids who are just below the line. They could easily meet the standard with just a little help from their teacher. And then there’s me. That last group on the left. Way below the standard. Way.
Now, the PE teacher could have helped me with my stride. He could have helped with my breathing. He could have had me run more in order to run faster. I could have been placed in a remedial running group with all the other low runners.
And none of it would have helped.
Why? Because I quit inside my head. My body could do it easily. But my head put the brakes on in a big way.
And it still does. As I go out to the Greenway to run (or jog or walk really fast, whichever you would like to call it), I can sense my head telling me it is time to stop and walk. My breathing is fine. My legs are warmed up. The Beatles are playing. Everything is fine.
So I tell myself I will run as far as that next park bench down the trail. I’ll go at least that far before I walk for a bit. And then, about 50 yards before I get there I find myself walking. It is my biggest frustration with running. It isn’t the running. It isn’t even the boredom. My biggest frustration is my brain telling me to quit when I know I can still go farther.
Let’s flip those scores for a moment. Instead of elementary PE class running times, let’s label them TCAP Proficiency. With what group of students does a teacher naturally spend most of his or her time?
- Some teachers thrive on teaching those upper level kids because it is so easy and fun.
- Some will focus on those kids just below the line. With a little push, a little encouragement, those kids might actually make it up into the proficient category.
- A few will focus on those kids at the bottom. They will see glimmers of hope, but experience a lot of frustration.
Those kids at the bottom often get extra help. They are assigned after school tutoring. They are put into an intervention class. There are numerous parent-teacher conferences. Extra work is assigned. Easier work is assigned. Less work is assigned. Kids are allowed to draw the answer rather than write it. Some can make videos. We put them in Glogster, Blabberize, Prezi, and anything else that looks exciting.
And often we see very little improvement. Why is that?
Because the kid has already quit in his brain. His mind has convinced him that he can’t do it. Her brain tells her to answer 6 questions, but quit before she answers the last 4.
Teachers can’t fix this. Parents can’t fix this. Friends can’t fix this. Only the child can fix it.
People tell me all the time, “Once you start running you will love it. You just need to get out there.” OK. I’m out there. I’m liking it a little better. I can even imagine myself loving it at some point. Thriving on it even. I get images of me in a 5K run. A half-marathon. A marathon!
And then my brain makes me walk 50 yards before I need to. And the reality of my frustration floods back through me again.
At 52, I can handle this kind of thing. I can push myself a little farther next time. I can push beyond my brain and let my running be guided by my heart. Its not easy. But I can do it.
But I couldn’t do that at 8. Or 12. Or 17. Or even 32. A lot of people can. Some of us can’t.
NOTE: This is not necessarily an “opinion piece” on students or learning. Rather, I wrote this blog as a way to start a conversation about how to help kids who have already checked out of school. What are you doing? What are those around you doing? We talk all the time about how a teacher has to motivate her kids. What does that look like? Is it working? I look forward to reading your thoughts in the comments section below (or on FB if you read this there).
Tags: