Highly Ineffective…Driver?
This morning I got in the car at the Starbucks on Sand Lake Road in Orlando, FL and set my GPS Navigation system to see how well it did to show me the way home. It was about 6 AM. By the time I got on the road, it had estimated my arrival time to be 3:15. Not bad.
As I drove across the Florida Parkway toward Interstate 75, I noticed that the estimated time of arrival kept decreasing. When I made my first stop some 3 hours after starting, the arrival time was down to 2:20. I had cut nearly an hour off my expected time!
Immediately my mind made the leap to TVAAS and using the gain in time as a method of evaluating my effectiveness as a driver. (Who wouldn’t, right?).
In education, Value Added is a statistical attempt to demonstrate the impact a teacher has on a student’s learning over the course of the year. A number of variables are taken into account in order to compensate for them (age, sex, socio-economic status, last year’s test results, etc). The idea is, that any improvement demonstrated by TVAAS is directly correlated to the impact of the teacher. So, if the student does what was “expected” by the model, that scores a ZERO (as a baseline). If the student does better than the model predicted, the teacher gets a positive number. Likewise, if the student scores less than predicted the teacher gets a negative number. And these numbers are part of what is used to determine if the teacher is effective or not.
No pressure, right?
So, I thought that if I arrived BEFORE my predicted time, that should be a positive number directly related to the driver. If I arrived LATER THAN my predicted time, then that would be a negative for me.
Positive : Effective. Negative : Ineffective.
But then it hit me. In order to arrive early, I would have to give up a couple of fun things I planned to do as part of my trip. I had planned on stopping at High Falls State Park and taking some pictures of the waterfalls. I also planned on stopping in Atlanta for lunch. Those things would bump my arrival time later than the prediction.
So I had a choice. I could concentrate solely on the numbers and making sure I was “effective” as a driver. This would mean limiting stops to bathroom breaks and pumping gas. I would have to scout out locations for both that were easily accessible from the highway to limit my downtime away from the car. Driving from point A to point B would be the only thing I had time to do!
Or… (and this is huge)… I could choose to both drive from point A to point B AND add my own value to the drive. I needed the rest I would get from walking around at the park. It was actually better for my own health to do so. And, I could find a place to eat that would expand my horizons, get me out of my own little world, and make me a more complete person in the process.
Teachers are faced with this choice every day. Because TCAP is so important for rating schools, students, and now teachers, it is the end-all of education. We don’t have time for cultural diversity. We don’t have time for field trips. We don’t have time for visiting speakers. We have these standards to cover. We have to test the kids to see if they are ready for the test. Point A to Point B. That’s it.
But what if I chose the second option in my classroom? What if I chose to be less concerned with TVAAS and more concerned about creating a well-rounded individual who would be prepared to go out into the world upon graduation? What if I did emphasize those field trips? What if I did attempt to expand cultural horizons? Would I be willing to be considered professionally less effective in order to be individually more effective?
These are the thoughts that went through my mind as I wandered through the woods of the state park. I thought about them again as I enjoyed lunch at one of my favorite places in Atlanta (the OK Cafe, in case you were wondering). I chose Plan B.
I arrived at home at 3:55. Some 40 minutes later than the test data should I should have.
I guess I have to be considered an ineffective driver.
But I was able to put joy back into the journey. And that, as they say, is that.





